Best Pizza in Athens GA: Your Ultimate Guide to Flavorful Slices

Embark on a delicious journey to discover Athens, GA’s best pizza! Known for its vibrant college music scene and the University of Georgia, Athens also boasts an impressive food culture, with a variety of pizzerias serving up mouthwatering pies.

best pizza in athens georgia 1

I’m gonna wager a guess that you like beer, too. If I’m right, then I bet you’ll love my guide to the best breweries in Athens, too!

What’s the best pizza place in Athens?

De Palma’s Italian Cafe stands out as the best pizza place in Athens. Renowned for its authentic Italian flavors and cozy ambiance, it serves up a delightful array of pizzas, from traditional Pizza Margherita to unique local creations. Perfect for any pizza lover looking for a taste of Italy in Athens, Georgia.

Downtown Athens is the go-to spot for pizza lovers. Here, you’ll find everything from traditional pizzerias to lively bars serving pizza with a side of fun. Whether you’re taking a break from shopping or looking for entertainment, these places offer a range of crusts, sauces, and toppings to suit every taste.

Venture into Normaltown or near the UGA campus, and the pizza scene gets even more exciting. These local spots cater to all preferences, offering specialty pies for different dietary needs and cravings, all served with a smile.

Key Takeaways:

  • Athens, GA is a hotspot for amazing pizza, from downtown to surrounding areas.
  • A variety of pizzas, from classic to specialty, caters to every pizza lover.
  • Fresh ingredients and great customer service make Athens’ pizza places stand out.

Best Pizza in Athens, GA Overview:

best pizza in athens georgia 1 1

De Palma’s Italian Cafe

This cozy spot is a must-visit in Athens for top-notch Italian dishes, especially pizza. They serve everything from traditional Pizza Margherita to unique local creations, all in a welcoming environment.

It’s not just the best pizza place in Athens, it’s the best Italian restaurant in Athens.

Peppino’s Pizzeria

Located at 950 Whitehall Rd, Peppino’s is known for its friendly service and tasty pizza. They offer a kid-friendly menu, yummy desserts, and a full bar, making it a great choice for families or casual diners.

Mama Sid’s Pizza

A favorite among both locals and visitors for its variety of pizza flavors and quality ingredients. The welcoming vibe here guarantees a delightful dining experience for all pizza fans.


Amici uniquely blends the atmosphere of a bar and a pizzeria. It’s a go-to spot in Athens, GA for those seeking a lively college restaurant and bar vibe. Amici is celebrated for its delicious food, offering a dynamic setting that elevates it from a mere eating spot to a destination for enjoyment and socializing.

best pizza in athens georgia 2

Ted’s Most Best

Located at 254 W Washington St, is a staple in Athens, known for its personal pan pizzas, fresh salads, and an array of Italian-American dishes like pasta and subs. The highlight here is the outdoor seating under umbrellas, creating a relaxing environment perfect for enjoying savory pizzas and enhancing the overall dining experience.

It’s one of my favorite casual restaurants in Athens.

Automatic Pizza Pizzeria

Automatic Pizza Pizzeria in Normaltown is the place for New York-style pizza lovers. This joint, with its welcoming atmosphere, offers a variety of pizza options, each a delicious exploration of flavor. It’s not just about the pizza; Automatic Pizza also features a great selection of beer and wine, adding to its casual and friendly vibe.

Mellow Mushroom Athens

best pizza in athens georgia 3

Mellow Mushroom Athens in Normaltown stands out for its creative pizza recipes and eclectic artwork. Known for hand-crafted, stone-baked pizzas, Mellow Mushroom allows customers to tailor their pizzas with a wide range of toppings. Besides pizzas, they serve calzones, hoagies, appetizers, salads, and desserts. Mellow Mushroom is more than a restaurant; it’s a lively spot known for its weekly events and specials.

They also have some of the best vegan food options in Athens.

Little Italy

A top pick for pizza enthusiasts in downtown Athens, Little Italy is famous for its thin-crust pies made with fresh ingredients. The perfect blend of crisp dough and rich toppings sets their pizzas apart. Beyond pizza, Little Italy’s menu features various Italian dishes like spaghetti, lasagna, and calzones, catering to a wider range of Italian food lovers.

Pizza Factory

Pizza Factory is a key player in Athens’ pizza scene, famous for its delicious New York-style pies. A great spot for takeout or a quick dine-in experience in downtown Athens, it offers a menu with both classic and unique topping combinations, including pepperoni, mozzarella, and mushrooms, sure to please all pizza enthusiasts.

Related Post! Where To Get The Best Tacos In Athens, Georgia!

Emmy Squared Pizza

Emmy Squared Pizza stands out for its New York-style pizzas, calzones, and notably, its sizable spicy chicken sandwiches. Emmy’s creative pizza toppings, including options like bacon and Italian sausage, offer a unique twist to the traditional pizza experience in Athens.

best pizza in athens georgia 4

Your Pie

Your Pie caters to a diverse range of dietary preferences with its vegan and gluten-free menu options. The KETO-friendly cauliflower pie crust is a standout for those seeking a low-carb, gluten-free base, complemented by dairy-free cheese and fresh vegetable toppings like spinach and black olives. They also offer a selection of nutritious salads.

Fully Loaded Pizza Kitchen

Fully Loaded Pizza Kitchen prides itself on accommodating various dietary needs. They offer customizable pizzas with vegan cheese substitutes, gluten-free crusts, and a plethora of toppings, including fresh mozzarella and red onion, ensuring a satisfying experience for all customers.

These establishments each bring their unique flavor to the Athens pizza scene, meeting a variety of tastes, dietary needs, and dining preferences. From classic New York-style slices to vegan and gluten-free options, Athens, GA, has a pizza spot to suit every need.

best pizza in athens georgia 5

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top pizza places in Athens, GA?

Athens, GA boasts several excellent pizza spots. Among the top are DePalma’s Italian Cafe, known for its authentic Italian flavors and marinara sauce, Automatic Pizza on Prince Ave, famous for its New York-style pizzas with a perfect layer of tomato sauce, and Mellow Mushroom, celebrated for its creative toppings and use of olive oil and basil in their recipes.

Which pizza restaurants offer delivery in Athens?

Many pizza places in Athens offer delivery services. Emmy Squared Pizza and Domino’s Pizza are notable for their best pizza delivery options. It’s recommended to check directly with your preferred pizza establishment to confirm delivery availability in your area.

Where can I find quality pizza downtown Athens, GA?

Downtown Athens is a hub for quality pizza. Ted’s Most Best, located at 254 W Washington St., stands out for its personal pan pizzas, salads, and Italian-American fares like pasta and subs. Additionally, Transmetropolitan (often called Transmet) on Eastside is another great choice, known for its delicious pizzas with a variety of sauces, including white sauce and traditional tomato sauce.

How does Emmy Squared Pizza compare to other options in Athens?

Emmy Squared Pizza distinguishes itself in Athens with its unique pizza toppings and famous spicy chicken sandwiches. They often use ingredients like shrimp and scallop toppings, offering a different experience from traditional pizzerias. To get a full comparison, it’s a good idea to explore various pizza places in Athens.

What are some local favorites for pizza in Athens, GA?

Local favorites in Athens, GA, include Ted’s Most Best, Automatic Pizza, and Emmy Squared Pizza. These places have gained a loyal local following, often praised for their high-quality ingredients, like fresh basil and olive oil, and consistently delicious pizzas.