Best Italian Food in Athens GA: A Definitive Guide for Food Lovers

Athens, Georgia, often referred to as the Classic City, isn’t just another of America’s college towns. Nestled near the University of Georgia and UGA’s campus, it’s a culinary mosaic where the flavors of Italy meet the Southern charm of Atlanta.

Have you ever wondered where to get the best pizza in town? Or perhaps you’re craving a cocktail crafted with expertise?

best italian restaurant athens georgia 1

Related Post! Best Athens Restaurants Near The University Of Georgia

What’s the best Italian restaurant in Athens?

In Athens, Georgia, the culinary scene boasts diverse Italian flavors. De Palma’s Italian Café reigns supreme for overall Italian cuisine. Those seeking an upscale experience should visit Osteria Athena. For unmatched pizza delights, Ted’s Most Best is the city’s top choice, blending tradition with contemporary tastes.

Beyond the classic city vibes, Athens is a haven for expats and locals alike. The server at your chosen restaurant might regale you with tales of Italy while serving a delicious pizza topped with fresh mozzarella and cream.

Guests and residents are often amazed by the proximity of diverse dining options. Whether you’re a Dawgs fan, an expat, a student, or just a visitor, Athens, GA, promises a gastronomic journey like no other. So, why wait? Dive in and savor the flavors of this vibrant city and find the best restaurant for Italian food!

Key Takeaways:

  • Enjoy a diverse range of Italian cuisine, from classic trattorias to modern fusion restaurants.
  • Don’t miss the unique offerings of Italian pizza, takeout, and delivery options in Athens.
  • Discover Italian-inspired dishes at Athens hotels and uncover the cost of Italian dining in the city.
  • Families, take note: kid-friendliness is a hallmark of many eateries. Whether it’s Carrabba’s Italian Grill or a local pizza joint, there’s something for both kids and adults.
  • Vegetarians aren’t left out. From gluten-free options to dishes bursting with tomatoes, mushrooms, artichokes, and onions, there’s a plethora of choices.

Top Rated Italian Restaurants in Athens

De Palma’s Italian Café

best italian restaurant athens georgia 1 1

De Palma’s Italian Café has firmly established itself as one of the best Italian restaurants in Athens. Beyond its delicious Italian pizzas, which have garnered rave reviews, De Palma’s offers a diverse menu that includes a range of pasta dishes. The restaurant’s charming atmosphere further enhances the dining experience, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Ted’s Most Best

Ted’s Most Best is not just a restaurant; it’s an institution in Athens. This long-standing favorite is renowned for its personal pan pizzas, salads, and a variety of Italian-American fares, including pasta and subs.

Diners can also enjoy the relaxing ambiance of its outdoor seating area, making it a perfect spot for both casual meals and special occasions.

Osteria Athena

best italian restaurant athens georgia 3

Osteria Athena is a beacon of elegance and authenticity in the Athens dining scene. Known for its homemade pasta, artisanal pizza, and a fine selection of Italian wines, Osteria Athena is dedicated to providing an extraordinary dining experience.

The emphasis on fresh and locally sourced ingredients is evident in every dish, making it a must-visit for Italian food enthusiasts.

If you love Italian wines, you’ll love Osteria Athena. You may also love some of these top-rated liquor stores in Athens if you want to pop a bottle or two at home.

Peppino’s Pizzeria

Peppino’s Pizzeria is a haven for those who crave classic Italian flavors without the hefty price tag.

Alongside their delectable pizzas, Peppino’s offers a menu that includes calzones, sandwiches, and vegetarian options. It’s a place where quality meets affordability, ensuring a satisfying meal for every diner.

ZZ & Simone’s

best italian restaurant athens georgia 2

ZZ & Simone’s strikes a balance between cost and quality.

Positioned as a mid-range Italian restaurant, it offers a comfortable dining atmosphere with a slightly more refined menu selection compared to budget options.

It’s an ideal spot for those who seek a blend of affordability and culinary excellence.

And be sure to walk off that big meal on one of the many walking trails in Athens.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top Italian restaurants in Athens, GA?

We can recommend a few top Italian restaurants in Athens, GA, based on online reviews and ratings. Some of these restaurants include Osteria Athena, De Palma’s Italian Cafe, and Ted’s Most Best. It’s always a good idea to explore local ratings and customer reviews before picking a restaurant.

Which downtown Athens restaurants serve Italian cuisine?

Downtown Athens has several Italian restaurants that you might want to try. Some of the popular choices include De Palma’s Italian Cafe and Ted’s Most Best, both located conveniently in the downtown area. Check the respective websites or call ahead to confirm their hours of operation and any special menu items.

What is the menu like at DePalma’s Italian Cafe?

DePalma’s Italian Cafe offers a wide range of Italian dishes, including pizzas, pasta, and sandwiches with vegetarian options. They also have a selection of wines and authentic Italian desserts. The menu may vary, so it’s best to check their website for the latest offerings and prices.

Are there any Italian seafood or steakhouse options in Athens, GA?

While Italian seafood and steakhouse options may not be as prevalent in Athens, GA, it’s worth considering some of the top Italian restaurants mentioned earlier, such as Osteria Athena or De Palma’s Italian Cafe. These establishments may offer some seafood or steak dishes as part of their Italian cuisine. Be sure to check their menus online or call ahead to inquire about specific dishes.

What is the best-rated Italian restaurant in Athens, GA?

Based on the available data from online reviews, Osteria Athena is highly rated, often receiving positive feedback for their authentic Italian food and ambiance. It’s crucial to take personal preferences into account, as tastes may differ. So, exploring various rankings, reading reviews, and asking for local recommendations can help you identify the Italian restaurant that suits your taste.

Are there any upscale Italian dining options in Athens, GA?

While there may not be many upscale Italian dining options in Athens, GA, restaurants such as Osteria Athena provide an elegant atmosphere combined with delicious Italian cuisine. It’s recommended to visit the restaurant’s website or call ahead for information on their dress code, menu options, and reservations.